A Multicenter Study on the Effect of Margin Distance on Survival and Local Control in Stage 1–2 Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Tongue

Background: Pathological close margins are considered a significant factor for local recurrence in patients with oral cancer. However, the oral cavity has complicated anatomical features, and the appropriate margin distance for each site is unknown. This multicenter, retrospective study aimed to determine the appropriate resection margin for early tongue cancer and investigate the need for additional treatment for close margins and stump dysplasia. Patients and Methods: In total, 564 patients from ten hospitals were enrolled in this study. Sex, age, performance status, T stage, tumor length diameter, depth of invasion, elective neck dissection, iodine staining, horizontal margin distance, vertical margin distance, pathological differentiation, invasion pattern, lymphatic invasion, perineural invasion, dysplasia in the resection edge, additional treatment for close margins, local recurrence, neck metastasis, distant metastasis, and outcomes were investigated. Results: Receiver operating characteristic analysis for local recurrence revealed cut-off values of 3.3 mm for horizontal distance and 3.1 mm for vertical distance. Patients with close horizontal or vertical margins showed significantly higher local recurrence rates, but these were not associated with overall or disease-specific survival. Furthermore, there was no effect of additional treatment in patients with dysplasia at the surgical margin. Conclusion: For early tongue cancer, a horizontal margin of 3.3 mm was defined as a close margin. Close margins were significantly correlated with local recurrence but did not affect survival. In the future, we would like to examine the concept of “quality margins,” including the surrounding anatomical features.